Skip to main content

Dancin' With Mr. D.: "Abolish the Priesthood" by James Carroll


Now, what would the prince of this world like to see more than what ex-priest James Carroll has called for in his recent screed in the Atlantic: the abolition of the priesthood of Jesus Christ. Why? He says because the Church’s reputation and membership have suffered under the continual revelations of sexual abuse by those he erroneously labels "pedophiles, in reality the homosexual network of priests aided by bishops(homosexual and heterosexual), and cardinals who’ve protected each other at the expense of many victims.  In his own words: 

Clericalism is both the underlying cause and the ongoing enabler of the present Catholic catastrophe. Only by dismantling the clerical hierarchy can the Church end the perpetual scandals, move into the modern age, and preserve the faith of its believers.
Let us set the record straight by quoting a victim of priestly sexual abuse: "both clericalism and homosexuality in the clergy are major proximate causes of the scandal. It’s not either-or; it’s both-and. That is why blaming one without the other is a form of ideological scapegoating [emphasis mine] which, in turn, both conceals and reveals the true root of the problem." So much for Carroll's mislabeling of the source of the sin as "pedophilia."

The former priests' screed necessitates stating moreof the relevant facts concerning the homosexual priest crisis, the latest in a bevy of scandalous behaviors which have attacked the Church since her inception at Pentecost in the first century.

Carroll goes on to push for transformation of the whole of Catholic belief: ending celibacy for priests, the exclusion of women from the priesthood, bringing the laity into positions of power, fostering equality for women as administrators in the Vatican: “Yes to female sexual autonomy; yes to love and pleasure, not just reproduction as a purpose of sex; yes to married clergy; yes to contraception; and, indeed, yes to full acceptance of homosexuals,” Carroll writes. “No to male dominance; no to the sovereign authority of clerics; no to double standards.” It seems to me that “yes” to sexual autonomy, the libido, contraception, and full acceptance of homosexual sexual activity in the world are, after “the spirit of Vatican II’s’ opening of the Church’s windows to the spirit of the age of the 1960s sexual revolution the root cause of the present crisis. Be not afraid. Jesus said,  Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you; and lo, I am with you always, to the close of the age. God needs nothing from James Carroll, but he? Oremus.






Comments