First Things, a journal published
by The Institute of Religion and Public Life, an educational institute aiming
to advance a religiously informed
public philosophy has thoroughly exposed
the new Netflix movie The Two Popes,
featuring Anthony Hopkins as an irritable Pope Benedict and Jonathan Pryce as a
beaming Cardinal Jorge Bergoglio, today is known as Pope Francis.
The plot has Bergoglio considering retirement but instead is
beckoned to see Pope Benedict in the Vatican. The two then spend days becoming
friends and Benedict tells Bergoglio he is going to resign and anoint Bergoglio
as his successor. Wrong.
Bergoglio
did not in 2012 fly to Italy to meet with Pope Benedict at Castel Gandolfo to
ask for permission to retire. The two men did not spend days together getting
to know each other. Pope Benedict did not give Cardinal Bergoglio advance knowledge
of his intention to resign. He did not tell him that he regarded himself as no
longer fit to be pope. He did not reveal that he had decided Bergoglio would be
the perfect choice to replace him.
Waters’ paragraph labels the whole movie, an invention from beginning
to end. What the film wishes to communicate is the story of how Pope Benedict,
an “archconservative” mired in outmoded ways of thinking, can find common ground
with a romantic soul, a “man of the people” who represents progressive values and
the inclusive future of the Church. All the “conservatives” need to do is yield the
field of ideas to the “liberals” and get out of the way. Thus Benedict passes
the mitre to Bergoglio because he recognizes his period has ended.
Comments
Post a Comment